Category: Q n A

  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1061, Book 12, Hadith 183 : What lessons can be learned about patience and preference in the context of the Prophet’s advice to the Ansar?

    Q
    What lessons can be learned about patience and preference in the context of the Prophet’s advice to the Ansar?


    A

    O people of Ansar, did I not find you erring and Allah guided you aright through me, and (in the state of) being destitute and Allah made you free from want through me, and in a state of disunity and Allah united you through me, and they (the Ansar) said: Allah and His Messenger are most benevolent. He (again) said: Why do you not answer me? They said: Allah and His Messenger are the most benevolent. He said, If you wish you should say so and so, and the event (should take) such and such course (and in this connection he made a mention) of so many things. ‘Amr is under the impression that he has not been able to remember them. He (the Holy Prophet) further said: Don’t you feel happy (over this state of affairs) that the people should go away with goats and camels, and you go to your places along with the Messenger of Allah? The Ansar are inner garments (more close to me) and (other) people are outer garments. Had there not been migration, I would have been a man from among the Ansar. If the people were to tread a valley or a narrow path, I would tread the valley (chosen) by the Ansar or narrow path (trodden) by them. And you would soon find after me preferences (over you in getting material benefits). So you should show patience till you meet me at the Haud (Kauthar).

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1061, Book 12, Hadith 183
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1062a, Book 12, Hadith 184 : What is the significance of the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) invoking the example of Moses in response to criticism?

    Q
    What is the significance of the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) invoking the example of Moses in response to criticism?


    A

    On the day of Hunain, the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) showed preference (to some) people in the distribution of the spoils. He bestowed on Aqra’ b. Habis one hundred camels, and bestowed an equal (number) upon ‘Uyaina, and bestowed on people among the elites of Arabia, and preferred them (to others) on that day, in the distribution (of spoils). Upon this a person said: By Allah, neither justice has been done in this distribution (of spoils), nor has the pleasure of Allah been sought in it. I (the narrator ) said: By Allah, I will certainly inform the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) about it. I came to him and informed him about what he had said. The colour of his (the Prophet’s) face changed red like blood and he then said: “Who would do justice, if Allah and His Messenger do not do justice?” He further said: “May Allah have mercy upon Moses; he was tormented more than this, but he showed patience.” I said: Never would I convey him (the Holy Prophet) after this (unpleasant) narration.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1062a, Book 12, Hadith 184
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1062b, Book 12, Hadith 185 : How does the example of Moses illustrate patience in the face of adversity?

    Q
    How does the example of Moses illustrate patience in the face of adversity?


    A

    The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) distributed spoils (of war). Upon this a person said: This is a distribution In which the pleasure of Allah has not been sought. I came to the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) and informed him in an undertone. He (the Holy Prophet) was deeply angry at this and his face became red till I wished that I had not made a mention of it to him. He (the Holy Prophet) then said: Moses was tormented more than this, but he showed patience.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1062b, Book 12, Hadith 185
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1063a, Book 12, Hadith 186 : What was Umar b. Khattab’s reaction to the accusation against the Prophet, and how did the Prophet address it?

    Q
    What was Umar b. Khattab’s reaction to the accusation against the Prophet, and how did the Prophet address it?


    A

    Muhammad, do justice. He (the Holy Prophet) said: Woe be upon thee, who would do justice if I do not do justice, and you would be very unfortunate and a loser if I do not do justice. Upon this Umar b. Khattab (Allah be pleased with him) said: Permit me to kill this hypocrite. Upon this he (the Holy Prophet) said: May there be protection of Allah! People would say that I kill my companions. This man and his companions would recite the Qur’an but it would not go beyond their throat, and they swerve from it just as the arrow goes through the prey.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1063a, Book 12, Hadith 186
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1060c, Book 12, Hadith 182 : Why is it important to compare different narrations of the same hadith?

    Q
    Why is it important to compare different narrations of the same hadith?


    A

    This hadith has been narrated by Sa’id with the same chain of transmitters, but no mention has been made of Alqama b. ‘Ulatha, nor of safwin b. Umayya, and he did not mention the verse in his hadith.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1060c, Book 12, Hadith 182
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1059e, Book 12, Hadith 177 : What significance did the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) place on his relationship with the Ansar compared to worldly possessions?

    Q
    What significance did the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) place on his relationship with the Ansar compared to worldly possessions?


    A

    When Mecca was conquered, he (the Holy Prophet) distributed the spoils among the Quraish. Upon this the Ansar said: It is strange that our swords are dripping with their blood, whereas our spoils have been given to them (to the Quraish). This (remark) reached the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ), and so he gathered them and said: What is this that has been conveyed to me about you? They said: (Yes) it is that very thing that, has reached you and they were not (the people) to speak a lie. Upon this he said: Don’t you like that the people should return to their houses along with worldly riches, whereas you should return to your houses with the Messenger of Allah? If the people were to tread a valley or a narrow path, and the Ansar were also to tread a valley or a narrow path, I would tread the valley (along with the) Ansar or the narrow path (along with the) Ansar.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1059e, Book 12, Hadith 177
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1059f, Book 12, Hadith 178 : What can be learned from the Prophet’s preference for the Ansar in terms of his relationship with his companions?

    Q
    What can be learned from the Prophet’s preference for the Ansar in terms of his relationship with his companions?


    A

    O people of Ansar! They said: At thy beck and call (are we), Messenger of Allah. Be glad we are with thee. He then turned towards his left and said: O people of Ansar. They said: At thy beck and call (are we). Be glad we are with thee. He (the Holy Prophet) was riding a white mule. He dismounted and said: I am the servant of Allah and His Apostle. The polytheists suffered defeat and the Messenger of Allah (may peace he upon him) acquired a large quantity of spoils, and he distributed them among the refugees and the people recently delivered (of Mecca) but did not give anything to the Ansar. The Ansar said: In the hour of distress it is we who are called (for help). but the spoils are given to other people besides us. This (remark) reached him (the Holy Prophet). and he gathered them In a tent. and said: What is this news that has reached me on your behalf? They kept silence. Upon this he said: O people of Ansar, don’t you like that people should go away with worldly (riches), and you go away with Muhammad taking him to your houses? They said: Yes, happy we are. Messenger of Allah. He (the Holy Prophet) said: If the people were to tread a valley, and the Ansar were to tread a narrow path, I would take the narrow path of the Ansar. Hisham said: I asked Abu Hamza if he was present there. He said: How could I be absent from him?

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1059f, Book 12, Hadith 178
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1059g, Book 12, Hadith 179 : What was the outcome of the Battle of Hunain and how did it affect the distribution of wealth?

    Q
    What was the outcome of the Battle of Hunain and how did it affect the distribution of wealth?


    A

    We conquered Mecca and then we went on an expedition to Hunain. The polytheists came, forming themselves into the best rows that I have seen. They first formed the rows of cavalry, then those of infantry, and then those of women behind them. Then there were formed the rows of sheep and goats and then of other animals. We were also people large in number, and our (number) had reached six thousand. And on one side Khalid b. Walid was in charge of the cavalry. And our horses at once turned back from our rear. And we could hardly hold our own when our horses were exposed, and the bedouins and the people whom we knew took to their heels. (Seeing this) the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) called thus: O emigrants, O emigrants. He then. said: O Ansar, O Ansar. (Anas said: This hadith is transmitted by a group of eminent persons.) We said: At thy beck and call are we, Messenger of Allah. The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) then advanced and he (Anas) said: By Allah, we had not yet reached them when Allah defeated them. and we took possession of the wealth and we then marched towards Ta’if, and we besieged them for forty nights. and then came back to Mecca and encamped (at a place), and the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) began to bestow a hundred camels upon each individual. The rest of the hadith is the same.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1059g, Book 12, Hadith 179
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1060a, Book 12, Hadith 180 : What role does the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) play in resolving disputes among his companions?

    Q
    What role does the Prophet Muhammad (ﷺ) play in resolving disputes among his companions?


    A

    You allot the share of my booty and that of my horse between ‘Uyaina and Aqra’.
    Both Uyaina and Aqra’ are in no way more eminent than Mirdas (my father) in the assembly.
    I am in no way inferior to any one of these persons.
    And he who is let down today would not be elevated.
    He (the narrator) said: The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) then completed one hundred camels for him.

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1060a, Book 12, Hadith 180
  • question #3 Sahih Muslim 1060b, Book 12, Hadith 181 : What can be learned about the Prophet’s relationship with Abu Sufyan b. Harb from the distribution of camels?

    Q
    What can be learned about the Prophet’s relationship with Abu Sufyan b. Harb from the distribution of camels?


    A

    ” The Apostle of Allah (ﷺ) distributed the spoils of Hunain, and he (the Holy Prophet) gave one hundred camels to Abu Sufyan b. Harb. The rest of the hadith is the same, but with this addition:” He bestowed upon” Alqama b. ‘Ulatha one hundred (camels).”

    Referensi:

    Sahih Muslim 1060b, Book 12, Hadith 181